---
title: Disadvantages of Safe Harbor 401(k) and the Best Alternatives
description: Learn the definition and disadvantages of Safe Harbor 401(k) plans. Find out the best alternative if you decide a Safe Harbor 401(k) is not right for you.
image: https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/hubfs/Disadvantages_of_Safe_Harbor_401(k)_and_the_Best_Alternative_-_FI.png
---

[![Carbon collective](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/CarbonCollective_August2021%20copy/images/carbon-collective-green-investing-logo-white.4f6047d4.svg "Carbon collective")](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k)

- About
- Employers 
    - [Sustainable 401(k)](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k)
    - [401(k) Comparison Tool](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k/plan-comparison-tool)
- Individuals 
    - [FAQ](https://www.carboncollective.co/en/knowledge/faqs)
- [ETF](https://www.carboncollectivefunds.com/)
- Learn 
    - [Sustainable Investing](https://www.carboncollective.co/sustainable-investing)
    - [Investing Basics](https://www.carboncollective.co/sustainable-investing/investing-basics)
    - [Blog](https://blog.carboncollective.co/)
    - [Tools](https://tools.carboncollective.co/calculator/)
- Log in 
    - [Carbon Collective](https://app.carboncollective.co)
    - [Altruist](https://app.altruist.com)

[Talk to a human](https://ask.carboncollective.co/f4o5dylkg)

[Sign up](https://app.carboncollective.co/sign-up)

[Log In](http://app.carboncollective.co/)

[![Carbon collective](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/CarbonCollective_August2021%20copy/images/carbon-collective-green-investing-logo.53b28bee.svg "Carbon collective")](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/)

- About
- Employers 
    - [Sustainable 401(k)](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k)
    - [401(k) Comparison Tool](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k/plan-comparison-tool)
- Individuals 
    - [FAQ](https://www.carboncollective.co/en/knowledge/faqs)
- [ETF](https://www.carboncollectivefunds.com/)
- Learn 
    - [Sustainable Investing](https://www.carboncollective.co/sustainable-investing)
    - [Investing Basics](https://www.carboncollective.co/sustainable-investing/investing-basics)
    - [Blog](https://blog.carboncollective.co/)
    - [Tools](https://tools.carboncollective.co/calculator/)
- Log in 
    - [Carbon Collective](https://app.carboncollective.co)
    - [Altruist](https://app.altruist.com)

[Talk to a human](https://ask.carboncollective.co/f4o5dylkg)

[Sign up](https://app.carboncollective.co/sign-up)

[Log In](http://app.carboncollective.co/)

**[Home](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/) > [B2B 401k](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k) >** Disadvantages of Safe Harbor 401(k) and the Best Alternatives

# Disadvantages of Safe Harbor 401(k) and the Best Alternatives

![](https://app.hubspot.com/settings/avatar/b799b30a83c5d19763b2fb70fc4397b7)

 Written by Breene Murphy  |  Reviewed by [Subject Matter Experts](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/subject-matter-experts)

Updated on October 1, 2024

 Fact Checked

 Why Trust Carbon Collective?

### Table of Contents

## **What Is a Safe Harbor 401(k) Plan?**

A Safe Harbor 401(k) plan is an employer-sponsored retirement plan that allows companies to make larger contributions than traditional 401(k) plans. This is because the plan is excused from some of the nondiscrimination tests that apply to regular [401(k) plans](https://www.carboncollective.co/sustainable-investing/401k-plan).

Typically, the [Internal Revenue Service (IRS)](https://www.irs.gov/) requires companies to undergo annual nondiscrimination tests to ensure that highly-compensated employees ([HCEs](https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/plan-participant-employee/definitions#:~:text=For%20the%20preceding%20year%2C%20received,top%2020%25%20of%20employees%20when)), Key Employees and average workers have a relatively balanced participation in a company's 401(k) plan.

The idea is to encourage all employees to save for retirement, not just those with high salaries.

Companies can offer a 100% match based on an employee's salary deferred contribution. Employers may also choose to make a non-elective contribution computed as a percentage of an employee's annual salary, regardless if the employee participates in the 401(k) plan. 

[![Have specific questions? Schedule a strategy call with a 401(k) expert.](https://hubspot-no-cache-na2-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/cta/default/20345524/5da4aa34-813f-4541-b8d2-16a0f2891c8d.png)](https://hubspot-cta-redirect-na2-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/cta/redirect/20345524/5da4aa34-813f-4541-b8d2-16a0f2891c8d)

The formulas for these are usually very standard across record keepers. 

For example, the basic match has a floor of 4%, meaning that the employer must match up to 4% of employee contributions. The non elective has a lower floor of 3% of employees salaries. This “non elective” will go to everyone who is eligible for the plan, regardless of whether they are contributing their own funds or not. 

With [Safe Harbor 401(k) plans](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/sustainable-investing/safe-harbor-401k), companies are able to offer a generous retirement plan to their employees without worrying about the complexities and costs associated with nondiscrimination testing.

## **Advantages of Safe Harbor 401(k) Plans**

[Safe Harbor 401(k) plans](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k/safe-harbor-401k-plan) are generally exempt from nondiscrimination testing and reporting associated with traditional 401(k)s. It means that less paperwork is incurred by employers, while employees benefit from greater access to their 401(k) funds.

Employer matching and non-elective contributions may be tax-exempt as business expenses. By contributing to their employees' retirement accounts, employers can potentially lower their overall payroll taxes.

It also increases their employees' retirement savings. Employees can max out contribution limits without monitoring how their contributions weigh relative to all others in the 401(k) plan. It can help companies to attract and retain top talent and boost employee morale.

Small businesses may also qualify for tax credits to cover the costs of setting up a 401(k) plan. Overall, these advantages can increase a company's bottom line.

## **Disadvantages of Safe Harbor 401(k) Plans**

Consider the following drawbacks of Safe Harbor 401(k) plans:

### **Mandatory Employer Contributions**

A key characteristic of Safe Harbor is that companies are required to make contributions to all employee 401(k) plans. It can be a percentage match based on an employee's contribution or a non-elective contribution based on annual salary.

It is the tradeoff for exemption from typical IRS nondiscrimination tests. However, it can be burdensome to companies that may not want to commit to making such contributions every year.

### **Costs**

Safe Harbor 401(k) plans can be a huge financial burden for businesses during certain years in which they do not have deep enough pockets to match their employees' contributions.

Since employer contributions to employee 401(k)s are required, costs can pile up. The more employees a company has, the greater the financial burden.

For example, suppose a company makes 3% non-elective contributions to employee 401(k) accounts. The company contributes based on employees' annual salary even if they do not participate or contribute to the account themselves.

### **No Guarantee You'll Pass Top-Heavy Tests**

Even if a business adopts a Safe Harbor plan, it does not guarantee that their company will pass a top-heavy test each year.

Safe Harbor covers employer matching and non-elective contributions. However, other employer contributions, such as profit-sharing, may not be exempted.

It can trigger top-heavy tests, which means the company must set aside funds for key employees. Employers must still monitor how contributions are being allocated to ensure compliance.

## **Alternatives to Safe Harbor 401(k) Plans**

If a Safe Harbor 401(k) plan seems unsuitable to your company's financial situation and goals, you may consider these alternatives and explore [sustainable 401(k)](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k) plans:

### **Individual 401(k) Plans**

These are similar to Safe Harbor or traditional 401(k) plans in that they offer the same tax advantages but with fewer employer requirements. An individual 401(k) plan is most suitable for owner-only businesses and self-employed individuals.

It is easier and cheaper to administer with higher potential contribution limits than other retirement plans. It also allows salary deferrals and profit-sharing contributions. Lastly, account owners have the freedom to choose which investments to make in their plans.

### **Profit-Sharing Plans**

Profit-sharing plans are another type of employer-sponsored retirement plan, where an employer contributes to employees’ accounts based on a company's annual profits or productivity.

The contribution is typically determined as a set percentage of the employee's salary and may vary yearly depending on the company's performance. Profit-sharing plans can be used to give employees a sense of ownership of the business.

It also allows employers more flexibility regarding how much money they contribute toward employee retirement savings compared to a Safe Harbor 401(k).

### **SIMPLE IRA Plans**

Another alternative to a Safe Harbor 401(k) is a Savings Incentive Match Plan for Employees. This type of individual retirement account (IRA) is designed specifically for small businesses and self-employed individuals.

A SIMPLE IRA allows employees to make salary deferral contributions, much like a traditional 401(k) or Safe Harbor 401(k). It requires no discrimination tests and is easily set up with lower associated costs.

Employers must match employee contributions up to 3% of salary or contribute 2% in non-elective employer contributions for all eligible employees. All contributions to the plan are tax-deferred until withdrawal.

### **SEP IRA Plans**

The Simplified Employee Pension (SEP) IRA may be attractive to small business employers who cannot afford to make employer contributions or do not want to commit to regular matching contributions.

SEP IRA allows employees to contribute pre-tax money into their own accounts up to the IRS annual contribution limit. The employer does not have to match contributions; they make a one-time contribution for all eligible employees each year instead.

Contributions are subject to nondiscrimination rules, and there are no filing requirements beyond Form 5500.

![Alternatives_to_Safe_Harbor_401(k)_Plans_(1)](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Alternatives_to_Safe_Harbor_401(k)_Plans_(1).png?width=960&height=1048&name=Alternatives_to_Safe_Harbor_401(k)_Plans_(1).png)

## **The Bottom Line**

A Safe Harbor 401(k) plan is an employer-sponsored retirement plan designed to allow companies to avoid nondiscrimination testing by the IRS.

Employers are required to make either matching or nonelective contributions on behalf of their employees, vested immediately.

Disadvantages include the mandatory nature of employer contributions, which can be financially burdensome depending on the number of employees a company has. Safe Harbor is also not guaranteed to pass top-heavy tests.

If a Safe Harbor 401(k) plan seems unsuitable for your company's situation and goals, alternative retirement plans include individual 401(k)s, SIMPLE IRAs, SEP IRAs, and profit-sharing plans.

Consult a [financial advisor](https://www.carboncollective.co/sustainable-investing/8-different-titles-of-financial-advisors-their-specialties) for further guidance on each alternative plan's details and decide which is the best fit for your company.

[![FREE PLAN CHECK-UP Meet with an Expert   ✅ Cost-Savings Analysis ✅ Proactive Compliance/Legal Risk Screening ✅ Performance Benchmarking ✅ Sustainable Investment Review ✅ Participant Experience Evaluation    ](https://hubspot-no-cache-na2-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/cta/default/20345524/interactive-127749612835.png)](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/hs/cta/wi/redirect?encryptedPayload=AVxigLJY9O3guXJFHZk3FXa%2FVjt15A7VtVt6RkRiz3qs4yH%2B54RAEcWVr8sgxwBwBgxUCTf3GK0yaomvZe4zAuA8v7cUFkOSUDbl9I%2BBUMXmJ8l1he%2B9DQV9Ef7SQ%2F7Mp0vMyJ6ZmkHkqz8kU%2BqRDqLAf7N9btDF7EPHzSlRurieRxrcLfpbMHY9hak2qg3r3%2FIU&webInteractiveContentId=127749612835&portalId=20345524)

## **Disadvantages of Safe Harbor 401(k) and the Best Alternative FAQs**

 

### **What is a Safe Harbor 401(k) plan?**

A Safe Harbor 401(k) plan allows larger contributions to be made to employees' retirement savings. It is designed so that employers make contributions on behalf of their employees without having to worry about IRS nondiscrimination tests.

### **What are the disadvantages of Safe Harbor 401(k) plans?**

The main disadvantage relates to mandatory employer contributions. With Safe Harbor 401(k)s, costs can be burdensome as the number of employees rises. Also, though this type of 401(k) plan is exempt from the usual nondiscriminatory tests, it is not guaranteed to pass top-heavy tests triggered by contributions like profit-sharing.

### **Are there alternatives to Safe Harbor 401(k) plans?**

Yes. Possible alternatives are individual 401(k)s, SIMPLE and SEP IRAs, and profit-sharing plans. You may choose depending on your company's financial situation and goals.

### **What is the vesting schedule for Safe Harbor 401(k) plans?**

Employer matching or non-elective contributions under Safe Harbor 401(k) plans are 100% vested. Typically, the vesting schedule is immediate. If not, the Internal Revenue Service limits vesting within a maximum of 2 years.

### **Can a company have both a traditional 401(k) plan and a Safe Harbor 401(k) plan?**

It is possible for a company to have both a traditional 401(k) plan and a Safe Harbor 401(k) plan. However, the plans must be run as separate entities and any contributions made by employees or employers must not be intermingled between the two. Additionally, it should be noted that if an employer decides to offer both a traditional 401(k) plan and a Safe Harbor 401(k) plan, the employer cannot cherry-pick which employees can take advantage of the Safe Harbor features. All eligible employees must be given equal access to both plans.

### Related Topics

![Attend Our Next Webinar](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/hubfs/carbon-collective-green-investing-icon-webinar.12af7b6e.svg)

### Attend Our Next Webinar

Join our next Sustainable Investing 101 webinar, get our favorite DIY options, and walk through how we build our portfolios.

[Watch Now](https://www.carboncollective.co/sustainable-investing-webinar-green-retirement-month)

![Get Our Newsletter](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/hubfs/carbon-collective-green-investing-icon-demo.6ed28722.svg)

### Get Our Newsletter

Go a level deeper with us and investigate the potential impacts of climate change on investments like your retirement account.

Join Newsletter

![close-typeform]()

![Talk To A Human](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/hubfs/carbon-collective-green-investing-icon-chat.49d48c5b.svg)

### Talk To A Human

Joining a new investment service can be intimidating. We’re here for you. Click below to email us a question or book a quick call.

[Ask a Question](https://ask.carboncollective.co/f70pooobq)

- Portfolios 
    - [Performance](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/returns)
- About 
    - [Sustainable 401(k)](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k)
- Learn 
    - [FAQ](https://www.carboncollective.co/en/knowledge/faqs)
    - [Sustainable Investing](https://www.carboncollective.co/sustainable-investing)
    - [Investing Basics](https://www.carboncollective.co/sustainable-investing/investing-basics)
- Contact 
    - [Contact us](mailto:hello@carboncollective.co)
    - [Legal](https://www.carboncollective.co/legal)
    - [Privacy Policy](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/hubfs/2022-11%20Carbon%20Collective%20Privacy%20Policy.pdf)
- [Back to top](https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k/disadvantages-of-safe-harbor-401k#top-of-page)

DISCLAIMERS:

Advisory services provided by Carbon Collective Investment LLC (“Carbon Collective"), an SEC-registered investment adviser. A copy of Carbon Collective's current written disclosure statement discussing Carbon Collective’s business operations, services, and fees is available at the SEC’s investment adviser public information website – [www.adviserinfo.sec.gov](https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/310129) or [our legal documents here](https://blog.carboncollective.co/legal-documents/).

The articles and research support materials available on this site are educational and are not intended to be investment or tax advice. Carbon Collective does not make any representations or warranties as to the accuracy, timeliness, suitability, completeness, or relevance of any information prepared by any unaffiliated third party, whether linked to Carbon Collective’s web site or incorporated herein, and takes no responsibility therefor. All such information is provided solely for convenience purposes only and all users thereof should be guided accordingly.

Investments in securities: Not FDIC Insured • No Bank Guarantee • May Lose Value. Investing in securities involves risks, and there is always the potential of losing money when you invest in securities. Before investing, consider your investment objectives and Carbon Collective's charges and expenses. Carbon Collective's internet-based advisory services are designed to assist clients in achieving discrete financial goals. They are not intended to provide comprehensive tax advice or financial planning with respect to every aspect of a client's financial situation and do not incorporate specific investments that clients hold elsewhere. For more details, see our Form CRS, Form ADV Part 2 and other disclosures. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and the likelihood of investment outcomes are hypothetical in nature. Not an offer, solicitation of an offer, or advice to buy or sell securities in jurisdictions where Carbon Collective is not registered.

© 2026 Carbon Collective Corporation. All rights reserved.

×

#### Fact Checked

Carbon Collective partners with financial and climate experts to ensure the accuracy of our content.

Our team of reviewers are established professionals with years of experience in areas of personal finance and climate.

They have contributed to top tier financial publications, such as Reuters, Axios, Ag Funder News, Bloomberg, Marketwatch, Yahoo! Finance, and many others.

This team of experts helps Carbon Collective maintain the highest level of accuracy and professionalism possible.

×

#### Why Trust Carbon Collective

 Carbon Collective is the first online investment advisor 100% focused on solving climate change. We believe that sustainable investing is not just an important climate solution, but a smart way to invest.

 We follow ethical journalism practices, which includes presenting unbiased information and citing reliable, attributed resources. Much of our research comes from leading organizations in the climate space, such as Project Drawdown and the International Energy Agency (IEA).

 Our goal is to deliver the most understandable and comprehensive explanations of climate and finance topics.

 Our writing and editorial staff are a team of experts holding advanced financial designations and have written for most major financial media publications. Our work has been directly cited by organizations including MarketWatch, Bloomberg, Axios, TechCrunch, Forbes, NerdWallet, GreenBiz, Reuters, and many others.

 We strive to empower readers with the most factual and reliable climate finance information possible to help them make informed decisions. 

 }

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Breene Murphy",
    "url" : "https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k/author/breene-murphy"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2024-04-15T16:23:30.975Z",
  "datePublished" : "2023-04-08T06:22:45.000Z",
  "headline" : "Disadvantages of Safe Harbor 401(k) and the Best Alternatives",
  "image" : [ "https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/hubfs/Disadvantages_of_Safe_Harbor_401(k)_and_the_Best_Alternative_-_FI.png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k/disadvantages-of-safe-harbor-401k",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/hubfs/CarbonCollectiveLogo.png"
    },
    "name" : "Carbon Collective"
  }
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "Organization",
  "alternateName" : "Carbon Collective",
  "contactPoint" : {
    "@type" : "ContactPoint",
    "areaServed" : "US",
    "availableLanguage" : "en",
    "contactType" : "customer service",
    "telephone" : "(650) 868-2697"
  },
  "logo" : "https://www.carboncollective.co/hubfs/CarbonCollectiveLogo.png",
  "name" : "Carbon Collective Investing LLC",
  "sameAs" : [ "https://www.facebook.com/carboncollectiveinvesting/", "https://twitter.com/carbncollective", "https://www.instagram.com/carbon.collective/", "https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC769Y-F-L_B37kyQfdpvyXA", "https://www.linkedin.com/company/carbon-collective/", "https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/carbon-collective", "https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/310129", "https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q110243690" ],
  "url" : "https://www.carboncollective.co/"
}
```

```json
{
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@type": "BlogPosting",
    "mainEntityOfPage": {
      "@type": "WebPage",
      "@id": "https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k/disadvantages-of-safe-harbor-401k"
    },
    "headline": "Disadvantages of Safe Harbor 401(k) and the Best Alternatives",
    "description": "Learn the definition and disadvantages of Safe Harbor 401(k) plans. Find out the best alternative if you decide a Safe Harbor 401(k) is not right for you.
",
    "image": "https://20345524.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/20345524/Disadvantages_of_Safe_Harbor_401%28k%29_and_the_Best_Alternative_-_FI.png",  
    "author": {
      "@type": "Person",
      "name": "https://app.hubspot.com/settings/avatar/b799b30a83c5d19763b2fb70fc4397b7",
      "url": "https://www.carboncollectiveinvesting.com/401k/author/breene-murphy"
    },  
    "publisher": {
      "@type": "Organization",
      "name": "Carbon Collective",
      "logo": {
        "@type": "ImageObject",
        "url": "https://www.carboncollective.co/hubfs/CarbonCollectiveLogo.png"
      }
    },
    "datePublished": "2023-04-08",
    "dateModified": "2024-10-01"
  }
```